Friday, March 2, 2012

What irritated me the most about this section, besides the obvious inhumanity of the situation, was that the people in Wiesel's community were so oblivious. They had too much trust in the world, always staying positive instead of realizing right away that their situation was horribly unjust. They lived in denial, doubting that all Jews were going to be exterminated, saying things like "Annihilate an entire people? Wipe out a population dispersed throughout so many nations? So many millions of people! By what means? In the middle of the twentieth century!" (8) and "The Germans will not come this far. They will stay in Budapest. For strategic reasons, for political reasons." (9) Basically, they told themselves anything to avoid accepting the bitter truth. This is understandable, because it's obviously hard to accept something when you know it will be extremely painful. But at the same time, living in denial isn't helping them. Perhaps if they had taken note of the inevitable they would have found a way to escape the tragedy of being sent to concentration camps. But instead, they basically let themselves fall into the trap. When ghettos were created, they convinced themselves that the new lifestyle would be helpful- "People thought this was a good thing... No more fear. No more anguish. We would live among Jews, among brothers." (12) Even at the concentration camps, at which officers beat them mercilessly for no reason, like dogs, they kept their optimism- "We mustn't give up hope, even now as the sword hangs over our heads." (31) It was really frustrating how hopeful they were. I'm not saying that optimism is a bad thing, because sometimes you need positivity to get you through. But it takes them so long to realize how awfully they're being treated and how hopeless their situation is; it's irritating.

5 comments:

  1. I completely agree with what youre saying about over-optimism. Often times, whether its on purpose of not, people shield themselves from the outside world. People don't want to accept the reality of how cruel the outside world really is. This book does an excellent part of demonstrating that aspect of human nature, especially in the sections you highlighted. The old saying, "ignorance is bliss" comes to my mind. It has long been questioned whether this saying is really true or not. In my opinion, it is true. However, given the choice between being falsely happy or knowing the truth about my surroundings, my choice is clear; I want to know the truth. I wouldn't want to feel a false sense of security when I am really in grave danger. As for the Jews who have been taken from their homes in the book, I respect their optimism. I cannot say this from personal experience but I am sure it is much more difficult to maintain a positive attitude than it is to just give in to all the negativity surrounding them. Optimism is a good thing, but like most good things, you can have too much.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I'm glad that you also picked up on how "oblivious" the people of his community really were to the situation, and it wasn't only something that Brian picked up on. Separating themselves from the rest of the country, and trying not to become part of the terrible things that were about to happen was not a great idea, and setting aside all thoughts of tragedy, can seem like a good thing but in reality, it really wasn't. I liked how you said they told themselves anything to ignore the truth, I thought that was the exact statement to be said about the beginning of this book. I don't understand how they have a choice whether to trust in the info they are told, and to just brush it off. For me i would rather know what's coming and try to run away instead of just staying their thinking and thinking were safe, we wont get hurt, when bam! They are taken away for not realizing the truth. It is always great to stay positive, but too much can kill ya.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Nick is wondering why Brian is talking in the third person

      Delete
    2. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete